Health claim

“Milk adds extra calories and carbohydrates to a protein shake, whereas water adds none.”

Claim checked — strong evidenceMedium risknutrition

Evidence Summary

Multiple well-designed studies consistently support this claim.

One cup of whole milk contributes ~150 kcal and ~12 g carbs, while water contributes zero calories and carbs.

Extracted from

Milk or Water in your Protein shake?

Darcy Kelly

The video compares using milk versus water as the base for a protein shake, discussing differences in taste, texture, and nutritional impact.

Watch breakdown →

Follow Nutrition

Get an email when new nutrition claims are evidence-checked — or when a verdict changes.

Free newsletter

Get the weekly evidence digest

5 claims reviewed each Friday. No hype.

Unsubscribe any time. No spam.

Milk adds extra calories and carbohydrates to a protein shake, whereas water adds none. — Evidence Review — MenHealth Digest