Health claim

“Protein shakes made with milk lead to greater muscle mass gains than those made with water.”

Claim checked — mixed / earlyMedium risknutrition

Evidence Summary

Some evidence supports this, but findings are inconsistent or limited in scope.

Additional calories and protein from milk can support muscle growth if overall diet is caloric‑deficient, but studies show the difference is modest and dependent on total daily intake.

Extracted from

Milk or Water in your Protein shake?

Darcy Kelly

The video compares using milk versus water as the base for a protein shake, discussing differences in taste, texture, and nutritional impact.

Watch breakdown →

Follow Nutrition

Get an email when new nutrition claims are evidence-checked — or when a verdict changes.

Free newsletter

Get the weekly evidence digest

5 claims reviewed each Friday. No hype.

Unsubscribe any time. No spam.

Protein shakes made with milk lead to greater muscle mass gains than those made with water. — Evidence Review — MenHealth Digest